Trusted Slip and Fall Advocates for Garden City and Long Island Families
The Saul Law Firm, LLP represents people injured in slip, trip, and fall accidents in Garden City, across Long Island, and throughout New York City. Our attorneys handle claims against property owners, managers, landlords, and municipalities, from wet floors and broken stairs to uncleared snow and ice and poor lighting. We identify who controlled the property, preserve the evidence that proves the hazard existed, and pursue compensation for medical bills, lost income, and long-term injuries. A Garden City premises liability attorney will review your case in a free consultation.
Why Injured Long Islanders Trust The Saul Law Firm
A fall claim often comes down to how fast you act and who’s fighting for you once the insurer pushes back. Long Island families choose The Saul Law Firm for clear reasons:
- A family firm, not a case mill. We are a family-run practice, and clients here are known by name, never by a file number.
- Deep personal injury experience. Richard D. Saul has represented injury victims for over two decades and leads the premises liability cases we take.
- No attorney fee unless we recover. We handle fall claims on contingency, so nothing is owed unless we win or settle.
- Free, candid consultations. We review the facts and tell you plainly whether you have a claim.
- Reach across the region. We appear for clients in Nassau County, Suffolk County, Westchester County, and all five New York City boroughs.
Every fall case gets the same early priority: confirming the property owner and the clock before evidence disappears. We’ve recovered significant sums for injured New Yorkers, though prior results don’t guarantee a similar outcome.
Where You Fell Decides Who You Sue
New York does not apply one rule to every fall. The defendant, the deadline, and the paperwork shift with location. Get the defendant or the deadline wrong, and an otherwise strong claim can be dismissed before it’s ever heard. We identify who’s responsible and which clock is running before that mistake happens.
Private Property
A store, restaurant, apartment building, or private home is governed by ordinary negligence, and the owner or occupant is the defendant.
A Sidewalk Inside New York City
A city law places the duty to keep the sidewalk reasonably safe on the abutting property owner and makes that owner liable for injuries caused by failing to maintain it, including negligently failing to remove snow and ice. That liability rule does not reach owner-occupied one-, two-, or three-family homes used exclusively as residences, in whole or in part. When that homeowner exception applies, the City may be the responsible party instead, and a claim against the City has its own 90-day notice deadline and a separate written-notice rule.
A Sidewalk in Garden City or Elsewhere in Nassau County
That city rule stops at the city line. Outside the five boroughs the analysis turns on state law and the village or town code, and Garden City has added local requirements.
Proving the Owner Knew or Should Have Known
New York stopped sorting visitors into invitees, licensees, and trespassers long ago. Since Basso v. Miller in 1976, a landowner owes a single standard of reasonable care under the circumstances, with foreseeability a measure of liability. What decides most fall cases is notice.
Constructive notice requires proof that the defect was visible and apparent and existed long enough before the accident to let the defendant’s employees discover and remedy it. A general awareness that spills sometimes appear is not enough. Ice adds a layer, because an owner is not liable for an injury from an icy condition occurring during an ongoing storm or for a reasonable time afterward, which is why snow and ice claims turn on weather records and timing.
Photographs taken before cleanup, inspection logs, prior complaints, and weather data move these cases. We go after that proof immediately because video gets overwritten long before a lawsuit begins.
Deadlines That Can End a Fall Claim Before It Starts
Most New York personal injury lawsuits must be commenced within three years. Claims against a city, county, town, village, school district, or fire district are tighter and carry conditions unrelated to how badly you were hurt:
A Sworn Notice of Claim Within 90 Days
The state notice-of-claim statute requires service within 90 days after the claim arises, though a court may permit a late notice. In a wrongful death case those 90 days run from the appointment of the estate representative.
Suit Within One Year and 90 Days
An action against a city, county, town, village, fire district, or school district must be commenced within one year and 90 days after the event, or two years from the death in a wrongful death case. A statutory hearing does not extend that period.
Prior Written Notice of the Defect
A separate state law shields villages from suit over a defective sidewalk, street, or crosswalk, or an injury caused solely by snow or ice on one, unless written notice of that particular place was actually given to the village clerk and the village then failed to repair it within a reasonable time. Garden City goes further, requiring notice of a defect to be a written hard copy delivered to the Village Clerk before the occurrence, and its code expressly rejects email, the village website, service-request apps, and social media comments. Even where a village has this protection, a claim can still proceed if the village itself created the hazard or specially benefited from the spot, so these cases are worth a lawyer’s review before you give up.
Any one of these deadlines can end a claim worth bringing, which is why the first phone call matters more here than in almost any other injury case. Whether a bar actually applies to your fall depends on facts a lawyer needs to check, so do not assume a village claim is closed to you.
Speak With a Garden City Slip and Fall Attorney Today
If you were hurt in a fall in Garden City, on Long Island, or in New York City, the sooner we see the facts, the more we can do. We will identify the right defendant, calculate your deadlines, and preserve evidence. Contact The Saul Law Firm to schedule a free consultation. Let our family help your family.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I still recover if I was partly at fault for my fall?
Yes. In New York, a claimant’s share of fault reduces the damages award in proportion to that fault rather than barring recovery, and the defendant must plead and prove you were careless. A 2026 amendment created a bar for claimants more at fault than the defendant, but by its terms it reaches only personal injury actions subject to the state no-fault motor vehicle law. A fall on a sidewalk or store floor ordinarily is not such an action.
If I fell on ice, does an ongoing storm defeat my claim?
Not automatically, but timing decides it. New York’s highest court has held that a property owner is not liable in negligence for injuries from an icy condition occurring during an ongoing storm or for a reasonable time afterward. That rule does not speak to ice already present before the storm began. We obtain certified weather records early, so the record shows exactly when the storm ended.
What should I do in the days after a fall in Garden City?
Report the fall in writing to the property owner or manager and ask for a copy. Photograph the hazard and the lighting before anything is cleaned or repaired. See a doctor even if you think you can walk it off, because some injuries surface days later and a treatment gap becomes the insurer’s argument. Then call a lawyer before giving a recorded statement.